http://www.themoscowtimes.com/opinion/article/why-russia-has-its-eyes-
Friday, April 18, 2014
Thursday, August 22, 2013
Saturday, May 25, 2013
Illinois' fracking and coal rush is a national crisis
As a sit-in movement continues at the office of Gov. Pat Quinn in Springfield, Ill., besieged southern Illinois residents who have been left out of backroom legislative negotiations over a controversial and admittedly flawed regulatory fracking bill are calling on the nation to contact Gov. Quinn and Lt. Gov. Lisa Madigan to "put a moratorium on drilling to investigate its full climate and health impacts."
Residents are also asking for concerned supporters to call members of Illinois' legislature to vote against a bill that health expert Sandra Steingraber has denounced as unscientific and unsafe.
Continue Reading...
http://www.salon.com/2013/05/25/illinoiss_fracking_and_coal_rush_is_a_
Thursday, May 16, 2013
Huge Victory in Oregon Builds Momentum Against Coal
Energycompany Kinder Morgan announced last week that it is ditching plans to export30 million tons of coal through the Port of St. Helens, Oregon -- a move thatfurther galvanizes the grassroots movement in the Pacific Northwest that iskeeping Big Coal out.
"Three down,three to go!" exclaimed Sierra Club Organizer Laura Stevens. "This proposalwould have meant a dozen mile-and-a-half-long, dirty, coal-dust spewing trainsthrough the Columbia River Gorge and dozens of other communities every day."
The three remainingsites coal companies have their eye on to build coal-export terminals are inBoardman, Oregon, and Longview and Cherry Point in Washington.
"The announcementcame just two days after we packed two hearing rooms in St. Helens to oppose are-zone that would facilitate coal exports, and the nearby city of Scappoose,where the council voted unanimously to pass a resolution expressing theirconcerns about the project," Stevens said.
Communities through Washingtonand Oregon continue to face the prospect of dealing with miles-long trains carryingtens of millions of tons of coal each year -- and bringing its harmful coal dustpollution with them. The coal would then be burned in energy-hungry East Asia,emitting carbon that would rival the infamous Keystone XL tar sands pipeline. The nightmarescenario has solidified communities across the Pacific Northwest, bringingtogether a coalition that includes environmental groups, hunters and anglers,farmers, business leaders, mayors and state leaders, faith leaders, and thehealth community.
"All of us locally involved in this love the Columbia River and ourenvironment here," Darrel Whipple, an organizer with the group Clean ColumbiaCounty, said in the Los Angeles Times."We have concerns about coal dust polluting the river, coal dust polluting theland. We have children and asthma patients who are at risk."
Activists in the Pacific Northwest have already won several battles.Just two months ago, Ambre Energy licked its wounds after the Oregon Departmentof State Lands tabled a decision on a dredging project for a planned facilityat Port of Morrow that would receive nearly 9 million tons of coal a year viatrain from the Powder River Basin. The state's decision to delay came two daysafter hundreds gathered at the state Capitol to demand that Big Coal stay out.
Congratulationsto everyone in the Pacific Northwest for this much-deserved victory!
-- Brian Foley
http://sierraclub.typepad.com/compass/2013/05/huge-victory-in-oregon-b
Wednesday, March 20, 2013
Celebrating a Huge Offshore Wind Victory in Maryland
The winds of change brought some great progress to Maryland this week when the Maryland Offshore Wind Energy Act of 2013 passed through both houses of the legislature. The offshore wind bill has been championed from the start by Governor Martin O'Malley, who stands ready to sign the bill into law.
This is a huge victory that is nationally significant for two reasons. First, it could well be the tipping point that allows us to finally tap the massive offshore wind potential off the East Coast. Second, it will ensure that historically underrepresented minority groups and small businesses will benefit from the jobs and investment dollars that offshore wind projects generate.
The bill will help develop a 200-megawatt wind project off the coast of Ocean City by requiring electricity suppliers to buy offshore renewable energy credits.
This victory comes after three years of hard work by thousands of activists who know that Maryland can be a national clean energy leader.
"We started this campaign with our allies in 2010 with a town hall meeting in Ocean City, out of which the Maryland Offshore Wind Coalition formed," said Sierra Club Maryland Conservation Organizer Christine Hill.
What makes this offshore wind bill even more monumental is that it will bring more jobs to historically underrepresented groups. It includes a $10 million development fund targeted to small and minority businesses to assist them in preparing to participate in the offshore wind supply chain and sets up a task force to study the feasibility of incorporating degree programs into Maryland's Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs).
The legislation was championed by various organizations because of this focus on providing key provisions for minority groups. The Legislative Black Caucus of Maryland was a major champion of the task force. We held a rally where over 100 students came out to rally their legislators to incorporate offshore wind degree programs at HBCUs. The NAACP's Maryland Conference also named offshore wind as one of its top priorities this year.
As Christine put it, "It's so great to see our state committed to replacing dirty, outdated fossil fuels that contribute to climate disruption with clean, renewable offshore energy that will create more jobs and safeguard our children's future."
This new clean energy can't come soon enough, as dirty and outdated coal plants are harming Marylanders' health. For example, the Charles P. Crane and Herbert A. Wagner plants in Baltimore and Anne Arundel counties threaten the region with dangerous sulfur dioxide pollution at levels more than four times what the Environmental Protection Agency has deemed safe.
Sulfur dioxide is known to cause respiratory problems, including breathing difficulty, asthma attacks, and diminished lung function. It can be especially dangerous for kids, the elderly, and those suffering from respiratory disease.
Offshore wind is a solid economic choice for the state. Based on a report from the U.S. Department of Energy's National Renewable Energy Laboratory, a major 200-megawatt offshore wind project would create almost 850 manufacturing and construction jobs for five years and an additional 160 ongoing supply and operations and maintenance jobs thereafter.
We hope this will inspire many other Atlantic coast states to move forward with offshore wind as well. Clean energy boosts the economy, creates jobs, and doesn't harm public health. Congratulations to everyone in Maryland who worked so tirelessly on this bill.
TAKE ACTION: Thank Governor O'Malley for being a champion of offshore wind.
-- Mary Anne Hitt, Beyond Coal Campaign Director
http://sierraclub.typepad.com/compass/2013/03/celebrating-a-huge-offsh
China's Wind Power Production Increased More Than Coal Power Did For First Time Ever In 2012
Amid all the news about coal and pollution problems in China you might have missed this one: According to new statistics from the China Electricity Council, China's wind power production actually increased more than coal power production for the first time ever in 2012.
Thermal power use, which is predominantly coal, grew by only about 0.3 percent in China during 2012, an addition of roughly 12 terawatt hours (TWh) more electricity. In contrast, wind power production expanded by about 26 TWh. This rapid expansion brings the total amount of wind power production in China to 100 TWh, surpassing China's 98 TWh of nuclear power. The biggest increase, however, occurred in hydro power, where output grew by 196 TWh, bringing total hydro production to 864 TWh, due favorable conditions for hydro last year and increased hydro capacity. In addition, the growth of power consumption slowed down - in Chinese terms a modest increase of 5.5 percent - influenced by slower economic growth, and possibly the energy use targets for provinces set by the Chinese central government.
Coal still accounts for 79 percent of electricity production in China, but fortunately that dominance is increasingly challenged by competition from cleaner energy, as well as government policies and public concerns about air pollution. The Chinese government's 12th five year energy plan (2011-2015) aims for coal to be reduced from 70 percent to 65 percent of energy production by 2015. In contrast, the Chinese government has ambitious targets for wind, solar, and hydro, and plans to increase the share of non-fossil fuels to 30 percent of installed electricity generating capacity by the end of 2015.
Expansion of the coal industry does not have many friends in China anymore. Major increases of coal power in recent years have created not only record climate emissions, but an unprecedented problem of air pollution and water overuse, triggering increased concern among the Chinese urban population and the central government. The record air pollution in January this year has changed the discussion about coal, and now prominent policymakers and opinion leaders, even vice-ministers, call for capping coal use, especially in the eastern populated and industrial areas of China. The air quality targets the government set for 2016 will require cutting coal pollution. Already last year the government set new strict standards for coal power emissions, requiring costly investments in filters. This year the government set new water use targets for provinces, which do not give much room for increased use of water for coal use in key provinces. Now the discussion is around controlling the total consumption of coal, in addition to emissions trading and resource taxes. The coal industry is surrounded by challenges.
There is another, very sobering side to the story, though: additions to coal power capacity, even if they have been slowing down in recent years, still stood at 50 GW last year, even more than investments in wind. So it seems that some of the total coal capacity was not used last year, due to higher coal and transport costs, and increased costs of environmental protection. The economic slowdown, and slowing growth of electricity use, has forced coal to compete with cheaper hydro and even wind. Companies will push to use that new coal capacity this year, so coal power could see some more growth this year than in 2012, unless there are strong mechanisms to cap the growth.
So while some of the conditions that helped new wind power production pass coal may not repeat this year, it is also clear that the coal industry will continue to be challenged and undermined by clean energy and by China's new policy priorities to address the air pollution crisis.
Li Shuo is a climate and energy campaigner with Greenpeace East Asia, Beijing.
http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2013/03/20/1744741/chinas-wind-power-
Wednesday, March 13, 2013
Coal's True Cost in India: 100,000+ Deaths per Year
http://theenergycollective.com/josephromm/197641/coal-s-true-cost-1000
Mountaintop Removal Coal Mining Poisons Appalachia's Waterways
I remember the first time I saw a mountaintop-removal coal mining site - Kayford Mountain in southern West Virginia. Those images have never left my mind - a barren landscape where there was once lush forest. And right around the destroyed site, homes where people were trying to live despite having the world blown up next door.
Their lives are never the same when a mountaintop-removal coal mine starts blasting. One major loss for these families is clean water. We expect our water to be safe and drinkable. Many folks here in Appalachia have streams or creeks running through their back yard. Kids from Kentucky to Tennessee grew up fishing and many of us still enjoy heading out with the pole for a lazy Sunday afternoon hoping to snag a trout.
Sadly, for many people in Appalachia that pristine ideal no longer exists. Pollution from mountaintop-removal mining has poisoned many of our streams making them dangerous for certain fish and other aquatic life.
Mountaintop-removal is the process by which companies use explosives to remove the peaks of Appalachian mountains in order to get at the coal underneath. They then dump millions of tons of rubble and toxic waste into the streams and valleys belowthe mining sites. This devastating practice has damaged or destroyed nearly 2,000 miles of streams, and threatens to destroy 1.4 million acres of mountaintops and forests by 2020.Mountaintop-removal coal mining allows toxic heavy metals such as cadmium, selenium, and arsenic to leach into Appalachian's local water supplies. Research shows that "residents in mining areas - especially mountaintop removal mining areas - have higher incidents of cancer, heart disease, kidney disease, birth defects, premature mortality and otherissues."
One of the key measures of water pollution from mining is called water conductivity. The Environmental Protection Agency has stated that "high levels of conductivity, dissolved solids, and sulfates are a primary cause of water quality impairments" downstream from where rubble from mountaintop-removal is dumped.
In other words, corporations dump the waste from their mountaintop-removal minesinto nearby valleys and at the bottom of each of those valleys is a stream which gets covered up. The water still runs through all that dirt, it just comes out the other side chock-full of pollution.
When conductivity levels get too high below mine sites, scientific studies show that some fish cannot maintain healthy populations. And when selenium, a key contributor to conductivity levels, gets above a certain point fish can be born badly deformed.These fish, and our water ways, are signals when the safety of our water and the health of our environment are declining.
Unfortunately, the four states that make up our Appalachian community - Tennessee, Virginia, West Virginia and Kentucky refuse to take the threat to our water seriously. West Virginia and Kentucky are actually both considering state action to make it even easier to pollute our waterways with mining waste.
The governments of Kentucky, West Virginia, Virginia and Tennessee have shown themselves unable to responsibly enforce clean water safeguards, putting our families at risk. That's why now is the time for our EPA to work on a real solution to the problem.
As part of the Sierra Club's 100 Days of Action on Climate and Clean Energy, this week we're focusing on the theme of mountaintop-removal coal mining. For the sake of our rivers, our community and the responsible stewardship of our land, it's time for enforceable clean water protections against coal mining pollution.
TAKE ACTION: Protect Appalachia's water from mountaintop-removal coal mining.
-- Mary Anne Hitt, Beyond Coal Campaign Director
http://sierraclub.typepad.com/compass/2013/03/mountaintop-removal-coal
Monday, March 4, 2013
Los Angeles Announces 'Coal-Free By 2025' Goal
Angelenos cheered this week when Los Angeles Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa announced his intention to sign two agreements that will make the city coal-free no later than 2025.
This comes at a moment in our campaign when massive rallies across the U.S. in February called on President Obama to take immediate administrative action to tackle the threat of extreme climate change devastation.
Here in L.A., 2,000 Angelenos showed up in front of City Hall to demand national action on climate change last month. The good news this week is that Angelenos' demand for clean energy is driving significant progress in our own backyard.
L.A. gets nearly 40 percent of its power from two aging out-of-state coal plants -- the Navajo Generating Station (NGS) in Arizona and the Intermountain Power Project (IPP) in Utah. These aging plants have become a financial liability for Angelenos as a result of the necessary and required retrofits at both of the several-decades-old power plants.
The prospect of Los Angeles being poised to sign agreements to get off of coal represents a pivotal moment. This would mark a major transformation for our city and would be the result of ordinary Angelenos coming together to demand change in the energy choices we make. In 21st-century Los Angeles, it has become simply unacceptable for nearly 40 percent of our city's energy supply to continue to come from aging, out-of-state, polluting coal-fired power plants.
When Mayor Villaraigosa took office in 2005, the city got nearly half its power from coal and a measly three percent from clean energy. What a difference eight years make. Los Angeles was the first city in the state to hit 20 percent clean energy. It recently launched the largest urban rooftop solar program in the nation, and it has reimagined its energy-efficiency program to create good careers while saving more energy. In the past year alone, L.A. has locked in enough clean energy commitments to power 330,000 homes with solar (that's basically the equivalent of Cleveland or Minneapolis).
The coal transition is as much an economic transition as it is an environmental one, and it represents a victory for all Angelenos. The city's new CLEAN LA Solar program (a solar buy-back or "feed-in-tariff") -- the largest city-wide program of its kind in the nation -- promises to create 4,500 jobs and nearly $500 million in economic development for the city. Toronto-based Solar Provider, for example, has plans to hire 30 Angelenos and to invest $50 million in Los Angeles as a result of the new program.
At the same time, the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power is ramping up its energy efficiency program, increasing its energy savings, goal which will help lower Angelenos' energy bills.
By leading on a transition away from coal, Los Angeles is showing how we can transform our economy to create jobs, clean our air and water, and improve the health of our environment. Crippling drought, devastating wildfires, and superstorm Sandy have brought climate change home. It's time for a renewable energy future that breaks our addiction to dirty and dangerous fossil fuels like coal, natural gas, nuclear, and tar sands oil.
The Beyond Coal campaign's activists and supporters, along with countless other organizations, have been at the forefront for a transition from coal to renewable energy to reduce our city's human-caused carbon pollution footprint. We look forward to seeing the details of the agreements being considered for the mayor's signature. It's imperative that the city continue to replace dirty coal with more of the clean energy that is already bringing new jobs and investments to L.A.
We look forward to continuing to work with the mayor, city council, and Department of Water and Power to finally end our city's reliance on dirty coal.
-- Evan Gillespie, L.A. Beyond Coal. Photo of Mayor Villaraigosa from Moapa solar project signing ceremony in 2012.
http://sierraclub.typepad.com/compass/2013/03/los-angeles-announces-co
Wednesday, February 20, 2013
Enormous Grassroots Response to Coal Export Plan in Washington
How many messages do you need to leave before theyget the hint?
One can only wonder what Big Coal is thinking after morethan 124,000 comments poured onto the desks of decision-makers who will beoverseeing an environmental impact statement concerning a massive coalexporting scheme that would alter Washingtonstate's coastline and send countless coal trains through people'sneighborhoods.
The issue surrounds Cherry Point, where SSA Marine wants to build an export terminal that would connect the coalmines of Powder River Basin with energy-hungry East Asia.
It's one part of a larger plan to open up the coastline tocoal exports and completely reverse any progress on the climate crisis. Itwould send millions of tons of coal each year through Washingtoncommunities and farmland, clogging up rail lines and roads and leaving coaldust behind.
The overwhelming response has caught the attention of thethree agencies in charge of deciding the plan's fate: the Army Corps, the stateDepartment of Ecology, and Whatcom County."We're looking at an unprecedented number ofcomments," said Washington Department of Ecology spokesman Larry Altose inthe Bellingham Herald.
The sheer number of comments means it will take months to gothrough all of them.
"Everyday this plan is delayed it proves that this is a muchbigger issue than what the coal industry tried to make it out to be," saidRobin Everett, Associate Regional Representative of Sierra Club's Beyond Coal Campaign. "There are huge consequencesthat the public takes issue with and the state is going to take the time toevaluate this in the right way."
Meanwhile, some from Big Coal's corner havefigured that the hassle of fighting entire communities is not worth it. InAugust, RailAmerica gave up on its plans that would have sent five tons of coaleach year through Grays Harbor.
Another coal export proposal on the table awaits in Longview,a few hundred miles south of Cherry Point on the Oregonborder. Community members and clean-air advocates are poised to take this on aswell later this year.
"This movement against the Cherry Point proposal has set up a great precedent for the next fight," Everett said.
http://sierraclub.typepad.com/compass/2013/02/coal-export-washington.h
Wednesday, January 30, 2013
January 30 News: China Burning Nearly As Much Coal As The Rest Of The World
As of the end of 2011, China was burning nearly as much coal as the rest of the world combined. [WaPo]
China's coal use grew 9 percent in 2011, rising to 3.8 billion tons. At this point, the country is burning nearly as much coal as the rest of the world combined.
Coal, of course, is the world's premier fossil fuel, a low-cost source of electricity that kicks a lot of carbon-dioxide up into the atmosphere. And China's growing appetite is a big reason why global greenhouse-gas emissions have soared in recent years, even as the United States and Europe have managed to curtail their coal use and cut their carbon pollution.
Millions of people worldwide are fleeing their homes because of environmental disasters. But the conditions in which the refugees have to take up residence in neighboring countries isn't regulated by international law. [DW]
A new study by the National Wildlife Federation has concluded that climate change in the United States is happening much faster than many of its animal species are able to respond and adapt. [USA Today]
With its carbon cap-and-trade system now up and running, California - the most populous state in the U.S. and the ninth biggest economy in the world - is ahead of the rest of the country in taking action on climate change. [Time]
While air travel only accounts for an estimated 5 percent of global carbon emissions, that share is expected to grow as air travel becomes cheaper and more accessible. [The Economist]
According to a study by researchers at the Zoological Society of London and others, a mangrove forest shared by India and Bangladesh that's home to possibly 500 Bengal tigers is being rapidly destroyed by erosion, rising sea levels and storm surges. [The Guardian]
http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2013/01/30/1513841/january-30-news-ch
Wednesday, January 23, 2013
Secretary Kerry's Solar Surge
On Monday PresidentObama made it crystal clear that his Administration "will respond to thethreat of climate change, knowing that the failureto do so would betray our children and future generations." But he alsomade clear taking action is much more than an obligation to posterity, it isalso an issue of American leadership:
"The path towards sustainable energysources will be long and sometimes difficult. But America cannot resist thistransition; we must lead it."
Now, with SenatorKerry's nomination for Secretary of State, President Obama has a uniqueopportunity to make good on this rhetoric by leading a solar surge.
Solar power hasundergone a historic transition from expensive niche technology to a rapidlyexpanding cheap technology that is experiencing dramatic growth rates. The bestpart is that the technology is ideally suited for many developing countriesmaking it an integral part of any U.S. international clean energy strategy. Whetherit's reducing peak power deficits, replacing costly diesel, or providing energy access to the ruralpoor, solar power can deliver. As conventionalenergy costs soar, and solar's benefits are more widely understood, it isplaced to grow dramatically. But to truly take advantage of this historicopportunity the U.S. administration needs to lead a solar surge and no one isbetter placed than Secretary Kerry.A solar surge requiresfour tactical moves that, taken together, would constitute big change:
1) Leverage cheapExport Import Bank (Ex-Im) Bank finance to spur solar development in emergingmarkets;
2) Expand OverseasPrivate Investment Corporation's (OPIC) renewable energy portfolio with a focuson increasing its off grid solar lending;
3) Work with the IFCto establish a $500 million solar PV funding facility for emerging markets; and
4) Push the World Bankto establish a $500 million off grid clean energy access fund (like the oneentrepreneurs demanded at Rio+20).
This may seem like alaundry list of asks but most of these pieces are already moving. All that isneeded is leadership -- just like the kind President Obama offered on Monday.
So here's howSecretary Kerry builds off Obama's leadership. The first step is to work withOPIC and Ex-Im Bank (the two agencies that contribute the majority of U.S.climate finance) to dramatically increase solar lending in emerging markets. Rightnow it's a tale of two agencies, OPIC is a clean energy champion and Ex-Imis a basket case. With Ex-Im's cheap finance to catalyze deployment, and strugglingdomestic U.S. solar manufacturers seeking new markets, this should be anobvious way to support and expand on previous stimulus package investments.
The next step is totake on the World Bank. The U.S. is one of the largest financial contributorsto this institution and much like President Obama, the Bank's president Dr. Kimhas made clear his desire to lead on climate change. Secretary Kerry can takeadvantage of this opportunity to work with him to establish a $500 million fundingfacility that will catalyze distributed solar investment in emerging markets by offering public funds that will leverageprivate capital. Think third-party finance for rooftop solar in the U.S., butin countries with hundreds of millions of roofs. Given how competitive solar istoday this should have already happened. Working with Dr. Kim to establish thisfund is an easy win for Kerry and the administration.
The final step will bethe toughest but most crucial. Solar and other distributed clean energytechnologies are the only way the vast majority of the rural poor will everreceive power -- at least according to the International Energy Agency (IEA). The World Bank has already helpedBangladesh install one million solar home systems so it's clear they can do this. But they alsorefused a call from the world's leading social entrepreneurs for a $500 millionoff grid clean energy access fund at the recent Rio+20 conference. The Bank says energy access andsustainability are a priority. Secretary Kerry needs to help them put theirmoney where their mouth is.
These relativelysimple steps will put concrete actions behind President Obama's words and setthe tone for Secretary Kerry's tenure. A tone defined by his embrace of cleanenergy and his conviction to take on climate change. Establishing thiscredibility will be critical because his much larger climate fight --eliminating coal and other international fossil fuel financing -- looms large. Startingwith a solar surge will rally the troops to his side and set the stage for theState Department to move from climate villain to climate hero and once and forall silence those who question the reality behind the rhetoric.
-- Justin Guay, Sierra Club International
http://sierraclub.typepad.com/compass/2013/01/secretary-kerrys-solar-s
Thursday, December 20, 2012
What Economists Missed: Why World Coal Consumption Keeps Rising
http://theenergycollective.com/gail-tverberg/162771/why-world-coal-con
Wednesday, December 19, 2012
Coal Exports Emerging As Major Climate Fight In The Pacific Northwest
by Jules Boykoff
In the Pacific Northwest, activists and their allies are ramping up for a full-throttle battle over a proposal to haul coal across the west for export to China. Big Coal's latest master plan promises to generate a second epicenter of climate-change resistance-our very own Keystone XL pipeline showdown.
With coal prices plummeting, thanks in large part to the spike in natural gas use, coal barons are desperate to offload their lucre. Showing ever-greater verve, they're dumping it in overseas markets, especially China. The US Energy Information Administration projects US coal exports will hit an all-time high in 2012 - some 125 to 133 million tons - more than doubling 2009 export levels and surpassing a record set in 1981.
When it comes to climate disruption, these are ghastly numbers. After all, 2012 looks like it'll be the hottest year on record for the contiguous US. The year brought devastating drought and catastrophic storms. While we can't peg any single weather event to climate change, this is precisely the sort of climate seesaw scientists have predicted. Meanwhile, the Arctic suffered record losses in sea ice and snow cover. And globally, 2012 is on course to become the ninth hottest year ever. Revving up coal consumption - the dirtiest of fossil fuels - is not going to help matters, to say the least.
That's where the Pacific Northwest enters the picture. Last week, the Oregon Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) staged what may well be the only public meetings on the permitting process for the US coal industry's hail-Mary moment: to convert the western United States into a railroad and barge pipeline for coal mined in Montana and Wyoming and hauled along the Columbia River to the Pacific Ocean for export to China and elsewhere.
This Morrow-Pacific coal export proposal, which is being pushed by Australia-based Ambre Energy, will annually ship overseas nearly nine million tons of coal. The plan has dredged up blistering opposition. The Sierra Club, buoyed by New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg's donation of $50 million last year, has made it a centerpiece of its Beyond Coal campaign. Groups like Columbia Riverkeeper and the Power Past Coal coalition have rallied locals to the cause. The Yakama Nation, Lummi Nation, and other Native American tribes in the Pacific Northwest have challenged the proposal's logic and merit. The Affiliated Tribes of Northwest Indians demanded a comprehensive environmental impact assessment while the Columbia River Inter-Tribal Fish Commission questioned the wisdom of hauling coal through at-risk waterways, which could undercut the tribes' treaty rights.
More than 800 people packed the meeting hall in Portland. Just before the event commenced, Cesia Kearns, a Sierra Club campaign representative, told me, "Coal is the culprit on climate change. If we continue to burn coal at current levels, much less increase them, we'll have no hope of turning climate change around."
This sentiment was shared by many people who asked questions or provided public comment. They interrogated DEQ about air pollution from open-topped trainloads of coal. They quizzed officials on the hazards the project could cause for salmon runs and other wildlife in the region. They asked about the effects additional coal-burning would have on climate change. And they pressed officials about the literal blowback that could emerge: coal burned in China produces mercury that wafts back to the Pacific Northwest.
Although the DEQ web site states, "The effects of climate change have serious implications for Oregon's economy and environment," you wouldn't know it from the remarks of their representatives on hand. DEQ officials squirmed left and right, claiming only a splinter-sized purview. Those in attendance openly guffawed at their egregious evasions. DEQ project managers repeatedly asserted that an array of topics - from the transport of coal to the proposal's effects on the climate - was "outside the scope" of their narrow remit. This was met with a sea of Occupy-style frowny fingers and occasional bellows of disapproval. With each outburst, the moderator threatened to shut down the entire meeting.
One couldn't help but walk away from the meeting with the feeling that the DEQ's fluffy banter about "meeting the challenge of climate change head-on" was a greenwash. The willingness of officials to take the company's emissions estimates at face value was alarming, their skirting of the issues was appalling. Each stiff-lipped response telegraphed approval for the proposal - you could almost see Ambre Energy's application slithering through the overlapping patchwork of jurisdiction, which DEQ officials used as an alibi for deflecting their responsibilities.
What also became clear at the public meeting is that activists are embracing the grubby struggle to keep western coal in the ground. If this coal is scraped from the earth and shipped overseas, it's a climate game-changer. DEQ has until the end of February to make permitting determinations - and they could always be trumped by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, which is also weighing permits for the project. But activists are already talking about Plan B.
Campaigners are not going to step aside while fossil-fuel bigwigs transmogrify the Columbia River into a gargantuan coal chute to China. One activist from Occupy Portland told me if the permits are granted and Big Coal's dream comes true, spikier tactics will emerge to gum up the gears. Climate mavens pay heed-this is shaping up to be the left coast Keystone. The direct-action battle may soon have another front.
Jules Boykoff is Associate Professor and Department Chair at Pacific University's Department of Politics and Government. You can follow Jules on Twitter at @JulesBoykoff.
http://thinkprogress.org/climate/2012/12/19/1359511/coal-exports-are-e
Thursday, December 13, 2012
Energy Shortages - Why Malthus Got His Forecast Wrong
Most of us have heard that Thomas Malthus made a forecast in 1798 that the world would run short of food, and that great famine would result. But most of us don't understand why he was wrong. This issue is relevant today, as we grapple with the issues of world hunger and of oil consumption that is not growing as rapidly as consumers would like-certainly it is not keeping oil prices down to historic levels.What Malthus Didn't Anticipate
http://theenergycollective.com/gail-tverberg/156061/why-malthus-got-hi
http://theenergycollective.com/gail-tverberg/156061/why-malthus-got-hi
Monday, December 3, 2012
Why India's Coal Plans Are An Illusion
by Justin Guay, via the Sierra Club
The biggest untold story in the world is now out in the open.
Despite warnings from the World Bank about the dangers of unchecked climate change, the coal industry has a global pipeline of nearly 1,200 plants planned, two thirds of which are in India and China. India alone has plans to build a coal fleet nearly twice the size of the entire U.S. coal fleet.
But if this pipeline has you thinking that a coal-fired future is inevitable, think again. The truth: The majority of plants in this global pipeline are nothing an illusion.
To understand the reality of the industry's plans, take a look at India. India's huge pipeline will require ~2.4 billion tons of coal by 2030. That's two and a half times what the U.S. currently consumes. More importantly, it's nearly five times the amount of coal that India produces. To feed this beast India is going to need a herculean effort to increase production.
Let's take an optimistic scenario where Coal India (CIL) - the state owned mining company responsible for 90 percent of domestic supplies - maintains a robust 7 percent annual growth rate. In this scenario, India would increase production to ~ 1.5 billion tons. Despite this mammoth increase in production, the country would still face a supply shortfall equal to 920 million tons by 2030 - an amount equivalent to annual U.S. coal demand. That's a jaw-dropping amount of coal and it's the "optimistic scenario" because it's based on the fantastical belief that CIL will maintain an annual growth rate it has only achieved twice in the past 10 years.
But this optimistic scenario looks even more doubtful when you take into account the woeful state of the Indian coal sector. Despite industry spin that "environmental hurdles" are constraining production, the truth is that India has simply not invested in the infrastructure necessary to mine and transport coal to power plants. Worse, the permitted mining expansions it does have are under heavy scrutiny as the coal gate scandal has already resulted in the revocation of dozens of coal leases.
To expand any further the industry will need forest clearances because remaining deposits sit under prime forest land. Getting those permits is already leading to a showdown with activists determined to preserve what's left of India's natural heritage. Which is why Prime Minister Singh's attempts to force CIL to sign fuel supply agreements are so laughable. Without solving fundamental infrastructure problems, or convincing Indian citizens to destroy what's left of the country's forests, those agreements aren't worth the paper they're printed on.
More importantly, though, even if CIL defies all past experience (and concerted opposition), the 920 million tons they will still need is roughly the size of the entire international coal market today. Unless India thinks it can lock down a monopoly on the global market, that will be extremely difficult to procure.
The more pressing issue is how much it will cost India to secure that supply. Coal prices in the international market have hit a two-year low, causing near hysteria in Australia where billionaires are decrying their inability to compete. However, even these "cheap" prices are still $90/ton - triple what India pays domestically. This is likely a temporary lull. Coal prices have been on a steady upward march for the past decade and there are no signs this trend will reverse course given that easily-accessible reserves are tapped, transportation costs (oil) are rising, and an "Organization of Coal Exporting Countries" (OCEC) is emerging. Geologically speaking, coal may be abundant. But economically speaking, cheap coal is dead.
In addition, communities across the country are fighting new coal plants. Their movement is rivaling the anti-nuclear movement in its global reach and efficacy at shutting down projects.
Taken all together, we can see that this enormous pipeline is nothing but an illusion. But don't take it from me. Best to take advice from the Reserve Bank of India who has called for a freeze on lending to this "distressed sector."
Justin Guay leads the Sierra Club's international program. This piece was originally published at the Sierra Club's Compass blog and was reprinted with permission.
http://feedproxy.google.com/~r/climateprogress/lCrX/~3/hbRxWPCFkDg/story01.htm
Wednesday, November 28, 2012
4-GW Tata Mundra Coal Plant Is A Test Of The World Bank's Stated Commitment To Address Climate
Nicole Ghio, via the Sierra Club
When Dr. Jim Yong Kim took over as President of the World Bank, there was hope amongst health advocates and environmentalists that, given his background, the Bank would reevaluate its support for deadly fossil fuel projects. Dr. Kim's assertion that a new World Bank report on global warming should "shock us into action" is a step in the right direction.
Now, however, he has an opportunity to back this rhetoric with concrete action as the International Finance Corporation (IFC) reviews the social and environmental impacts of its $450 million loan for the enormous four-gigawatt Tata Mundra coal plant in Gujarat, India.
This review is an important step towards rectifying the impact the project has had on the 10,000 local villagers who rely on the land and water the plant is destroying. Dust and ash from the project is contaminating fish and salt flats, while livestock that used to roam freely can no longer access the commons for grazing. And both villagers and animals are forced to breathe air and drink water contaminated by toxic pollution. All of these are impacts from just Tata Mundra. The sad reality is cumulative impacts are much larger, as it is sited right next to the even bigger 4,620 MW Adani coal plant.
Thousands have been displaced, and those who have stayed are face drastic health and economic risks, all for electricity that they will never be able to afford (PDF). That's because Tata Corporation dramatically lowballed the price they would pay for imported coal, and used this estimate to claim they could provide power at below-market rate in order to secure approval from the Indian government and funding from the IFC. Then, after construction started, they went back to the government, acknowledged that the project would run at a 270% annual loss, and demanded that they be allowed to raise rates on average citizens, destroying any notion that the project would ever help provide energy access for the poor.
This situation is hardly unique. Across India, funding for coal projects is drying up as lenders realize that the projects are expensive, unreliable, and likely to go bankrupt.
The IFC approved funding for the project despite the clear warning signs, once again acquiescing to the long standing belief that coal is cheap, and its impacts on local communities and the environment should therefore be ignored. While the review is technically independent, how the World Bank responds to the recommendations lies entirely at Dr. Kim's feet. He will have an opportunity to take back the rubber stamp and help make right any violations the CAO finds. His decision on Tata Mundra will be a referendum on his ability to protect the health and environment of those impacted by the World Bank. We're hoping he lives up to his reputation.
Nicole Ghio is a Sierra Club Campaign Liaison. This piece was originally published at the Sierra Club's Compass Blog and was reprinted with permission.
http://feedproxy.google.com/~r/climateprogress/lCrX/~3/HZe5YDH2N2U/story01.htm
Wednesday, June 13, 2012
Poisoning the Great Lakes: 25 Coal-fired Power Plants Responsible For Half the Region's Mercury Pollution
CHICAGO, June 6, 2012 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- Just ahead of a major U.S. Senate vote on the Environmental Protection Agency's authority to clean up mercury and other toxic air pollutants, a Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) report shows that the 25 worst coal-fired power plants account for more than half of the dangerous mercury pollution emitted by the total of 144 electricity generation facilities in the Great Lakes region. The report also finds that almost 90 percent of the toxic emissions could be eliminated with off-the-shelf technologies.
According to "Poisoning the Great Lakes: Mercury Emissions from Coal-Fired Power Plants In the Great Lakes Region," Ohio emits the largest amount of mercury from coal-fired power plants (21 percent of the total in the Great Lakes region), followed closely by Pennsylvania (20 percent) and Indiana (16 percent). The remaining five states in the region rank as follows: Michigan (14 percent); Illinois (11 percent); Wisconsin (9.5 percent); Minnesota (6.5 percent); and New York (2 percent). Plants from outside the region also contribute to mercury pollution in the Great Lakes.
The Great Lakes region's five worst coal-fired power plants for mercury pollution are: Shawville (Clearfield County, PA); Monroe (Monroe County, MI); Homer City (Indiana County, PA); Cardinal (Jefferson County, OH); and Sherburne County (Sherburne County, MN). (See the complete list below of the worst 25.) A dozen power plants in Ohio and Indiana -- owned in whole or part by American Electric Power -- accounted for 19 percent of all mercury emitted in 2010 from the total of 144 coal-fired power plants in the region.
U.S. Senator James Inhofe, R-OK, recently filed a Congressional Review Act (CRA) resolution (S.J. Res. 37) to void health standards reducing mercury and other toxic air pollution from power plants and to permanently block EPA from re-issuing similar safeguards.
Thomas Cmar, attorney, Natural Resources Defense Council office in Chicago, said: "Mercury is a dangerous brain poison that doesn't belong in our Great Lakes. It puts the health of kids and pregnant women at risk and adds an unwelcome danger to eating what our fishermen catch. That's why it is so important that we support the EPA's standards to reduce mercury pollution by holding polluters accountable. Even more critical is that every single U.S. Senator from the region stand up for the Lakes by rejecting reckless attempts to derail the long overdue Clean Air Act updates that can help tame this problem."
Cindy Copeland, report author and formerly with the EPA Air Program, said: "Mercury is poisoning the Great Lakes and the three states - Ohio, Indiana and Pennsylvania -- that impose no rules are by far the worst offenders. Airborne mercury from coal-fired power plants in the Great Lakes Region harms our health, and the benefits of reducing mercury emissions are well worth the cost. With a reduction of health costs to the economy at up to $90 billion, it is hard to say no to this."
In the Great Lakes region, there are more than 144 coal-fired power plants which pumped over 13,000 pounds of mercury into the air in 2010. Mercury pollution from these plants' region accounts for close to 25 percent of the nation's total. The Great Lakes region is comprised of the five Great Lakes (Erie, Ontario, Huron, Michigan, and Superior) and the eight surrounding states (Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, Minnesota, Ohio, Pennsylvania, New York, and Wisconsin).
Eating poisoned fish is the primary cause of mercury poisoning of humans. Mercury is a neurotoxin that harms the brain, heart, central nervous system, kidneys, lungs, and immune system. Young children and developing fetuses are most at risk, and can suffer developmental problems from mercury poisoning.
THE WORST-25 GREAT LAKES REGION COAL-FIRED POWER PLANTS
- Shawville (Clearfield Cty, PA)
- Monroe (Monroe Cty, MI)
- Homer City (Indiana Cty, PA)
- Cardinal (Jefferson Cty, OH)
- Sherburne County (Sherburne Cty, MN)
- Muskingum River (Washington Cty, OH)
- Hatfield's Ferry (Fayette Cty, PA)
- Walter C Beckjord (Clermont Cty, OH)
- Wabash River (Vigo Cty, IN)
- Newton (Jasper Cty, IL)
- Pleasant Prairie (Kenosha Cty, WI)
- Belle River (St. Clair Cty, MI)
- Clifty Creek (Jefferson Cty, IN)
- Columbia (Columbia Cty, WI)
- St Clair (St Clair Cty, MI)
- Rockport (Spencer Cty, IN)
- Gavin (Gallia Cty, OH)
- Bruce Mansfield (Beaver Cty, PA)
- South Oak Creek (Milwaukee Cty, WI)
- Kyger Creek (Gallia Cty, OH)
- State Line (Lake Cty, IN)
- J M Stuart (Brown Cty, OH)
- Tanners Creek (Dearborn Cty, IN)
- Boswell (Itasca Cty, MN)
- Joppa Steam (Massac Cty, IL)
Based on projected reductions in fine particulate emissions due to the combined benefits of various air toxic pollution controls, the EPA has projected that the benefits of its Mercury and Air Toxics Standards (MATS) far outweigh the costs of pollution controls. The health benefits of the MATS are projected to be worth $37 to $90 billion in 2016 alone. The EPA has projected that the majority of the benefits would be reaped in the eastern United States, including the Great Lakes region.
Mercury emitted into the air from coal-fired power plants is by far the leading man-made source of mercury reaching the Great Lakes and the lakes, rivers, and streams of the Great Lakes region. This report lists the top 25 mercury emitting plants in the region. Mercury pollution from plants outside the region also contributes to the overall quantity of mercury found in the Great Lakes. When coal is burned to produce electricity, mercury is emitted into the air. The EPA estimates that coal-fired power plants are the largest man-made source of mercury pollution, accounting for 50 percent of mercury air emissions in the United States.
The Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) is an international nonprofit environmental organization with more than 1.3 million members and online activists. Since 1970, our lawyers, scientists, and other environmental specialists have worked to protect the world's natural resources, public health, and the environment. NRDC has offices in New York City, Washington, D.C., Los Angeles, San Francisco, Chicago, Livingston, Montana, and Beijing. Visit us at www.nrdc.org and follow us on Twitter @NRDC.
SOURCE Natural Resources Defense Council, New York
Web Site: http://www.nrdc.org
Deaths from dirty coal-fired power plants cost more than the value of the electricity
WASHINGTON, June 7, 2012 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- Up to 5,700 deaths a year can be attributed to 51 of the dirtiest coal fired power plants in the United States with no announced plans for sulfur dioxide (SO2) clean-up measures, according to a new report from the nonprofit Environmental Integrity Project (EIP). Even using the most conservative estimate, the estimated cost to society of the premature deaths caused by 18 of the power plants actually exceeded the retail value of the electricity generated by each facility in 2011. (See the full list below.)
Available online at http://www.environmentalintegrity.org, the new report titled, "Net Loss: Comparing the Cost of Pollution vs. the Value of Electricity from 51 Coal-Fired Plants," reviews U.S. coal-fired power plants with the largest emissions of sulfur dioxide in 2010 and 2011 that do not yet have plans to install or upgrade scrubbers. For the report, Dr. Jonathan Levy of the Boston University School of Public Health estimated the premature deaths in 2011 due to fine particle exposures caused by emissions of sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxide, and particulate matter from each of these plants, using a peer-reviewed approach consistent with EPA methods and an upper and lower bound for premature mortality based on two benchmark studies the EPA has relied upon in rulemaking.
Key findings include:
- The 51 plants contributed to between 2,700 and 5,700 premature deaths in 2011 alone.
- Estimated pollution-related premature deaths were highest at the following plants: Labadie, MO (140 to 290); Eastlake, OH (120 to 240); Yates, GA (110 to 220); Martin Lake, TX (100 to 220); and Mill Creek, KY (100 to 210).
- Applying the same standard statistical value for human life used by EPA, the 2,700-5,700 premature deaths identified in the report are linked to social costs of $23 to $47 billion.
- Using the most conservative benchmark in the study, 18 of the 51 plants in this survey contribute to premature deaths that cost society more than the estimated retail value of the electricity they generated in 2011. When using the upper bound to estimate premature deaths, an additional 20 plants had social costs exceeding the estimated retail value of their electricity in 2011.
Jonathan Levy, professor of Environmental Health, Boston University School of Public Health, said: "My analysis estimates that fine particulate matter concentrations attributable to the 51 power plants I was asked to review contributed to between 2,700 and 5,700 premature deaths in 2011. This was based on reported emissions data and outputs based on my peer-reviewed model of health damages from power plants. The relationship between fine particulate matter pollution and premature mortality is well established, and the data are sufficient to provide a reasonable estimate of the number of premature deaths that will result from power plant emissions that increase fine particulate matter concentrations."
For example, Dr. Levy estimates that fine particle pollution from the Southern Company's Yates plant in Georgia contributed to between 100 and 220 deaths in 2011, at a cost to society of between 800 million and 1.8 billion dollars. The retail value of the electricity the plant generated in 2011 was estimated to be roughly $400 million, which means that the social cost of premature mortality caused by the plant's pollution was between $450 million and $1.4 billion greater than the value of the electricity it generated.
In order, the full list of the 18 coal-fired power plants mentioned above is as follows:
- Yates Steam Generating Plant, Coweta County, GA; 2011 net value (retail sales - cost of premature deaths): -$461 million; 2011 premature deaths: 100 - 220; cost of premature deaths: $870 - $1800 million; 2011 retail value of electricity: $409 million.
- Eastlake Power Plant, Lake County, OH; 2011 net value (retail sales - cost of premature deaths): -$375 million; 2011 premature deaths: 120 - 240; cost of premature deaths: $980 - $2000 million; 2011 retail value of electricity: $605 million.
- Green River Generating Station, Muhlenberg County, KY; 2011 net value (retail sales - cost of premature deaths): -$299 million; 2011 premature deaths: 44 - 88; cost of premature deaths: $360 - $730 million; 2011 retail value of electricity: $61 million.
- Johnsonville Fossil Plant, Humphreys County, TN; 2011 net value (retail sales - cost of premature deaths): -$269 million; 2011 premature deaths: 85 - 170; cost of premature deaths: $700 - $1400 million; 2011 retail value of electricity: $431 million.
- Kammer Plant, Marshall County, WV; 2011 net value (retail sales - cost of premature deaths): -$260 million; 2011 premature deaths: 48 - 98; cost of premature deaths: $400 - $810 million; 2011 retail value of electricity: $140 million.
- Mill Creek Generating Station, Jefferson County, KY; 2011 net value (retail sales - cost of premature deaths): -$226 million; 2011 premature deaths: 100 - 210; cost of premature deaths: $870 - $1700 million; 2011 retail value of electricity: $644 million.
- Greene County Steam Plant, Greene County, AL; 2011 net value (retail sales - cost of premature deaths): -$190 million; 2011 premature deaths: 49 - 100; cost of premature deaths: $410 - $850 million; 2011 retail value of electricity: $220 million.
- Canadys Steam Electric Generating Plant, Colleton County, SC; 2011 net value (retail sales - cost of premature deaths): -$162 million; 2011 premature deaths: 37 - 75; cost of premature deaths: $300 - $620 million; 2011 retail value of electricity: $138 million.
- Yorktown Power Station, York County, VA; 2011 net value (retail sales - cost of premature deaths): -$156 million; 2011 premature deaths: 34 - 68; cost of premature deaths: $280 - $570 million; 2011 retail value of electricity: $124 million.
- Nelson Dewey Generating Station, Grant County, WI; 2011 net value (retail sales - cost of premature deaths): -$132 million; 2011 premature deaths: 29 - 61; cost of premature deaths: $240 - $500 million; 2011 retail value of electricity: $108 million.
- Jack McDonough Steam Generating Plant, Cobb County, GA; 2011 net value (retail sales - cost of premature deaths): -$119 million; 2011 premature deaths: 40 - 82; cost of premature deaths: $330 - $680 million; 2011 retail value of electricity: $211 million.
- Trenton Channel Power Plant, Wayne County, MI; 2011 net value (retail sales - cost of premature deaths): -$102 million; 2011 premature deaths: 56 - 110; cost of premature deaths: $460 - $950 million; 2011 retail value of electricity: $358 million.
- Phil Sporn Power Plant, Mason County,WV; 2011 net value (retail sales - cost of premature deaths): -$102 million; 2011 premature deaths: 27 - 53; cost of premature deaths: $220 - $440 million; 2011 retail value of electricity: $118 million.
- L V Sutton Steam Plant, New Hanover County, NC; 2011 net value (retail sales - cost of premature deaths): -$75 million; 2011 premature deaths: 24 - 48; cost of premature deaths: $200 - $400 million; 2011 retail value of electricity: $125 million.
- H F Lee Steam Electric Plant, Wayne County, NC; 2011 net value (retail sales - cost of premature deaths): -$58 million; 2011 premature deaths: 19 - 39; cost of premature deaths: $160 - $330 million; 2011 retail value of electricity: $102 million.
- Big Brown Steam Electric Station, Freestone County, TX; 2011 net value (retail sales - cost of premature deaths): -$54 million; 2011 premature deaths: 94 - 200; cost of premature deaths: $780 - $1700 million; 2011 retail value of electricity: $726 million.
- Shawnee Fossil Plant, McCracken County, KY; 2011 net value (retail sales - cost of premature deaths): -$23 million; 2011 premature deaths: 70 - 140; cost of premature deaths: $580 - $1200 million; 2011 retail value of electricity: $557 million.
- Meramec Power Plant, Saint Louis County, MO; 2011 net value (retail sales - cost of premature deaths): -$13 million; 2011 premature deaths: 57 - 110; cost of premature deaths: $470 - $950 million; 2011 retail value of electricity: $457 million.
SOURCE Environmental Integrity Project, Washington, D.C.
Web Site: http://www.environmentalintegrity.org