Tuesday, October 13, 2009

Scrubbed emissions from coal plants ending up in the water

This is a case of solving one problem and creating yet another. A NY Times article reports on how scrubbing emissions at coal fired power plants results in toxic chemicals going into the water system. Given that water resources are tight it is insane to make the water unsafe by adding pollution but at the same time it's insane to simply let this pollution go into the air. On the one hand there's a way to reduce the toxicity of burning coal in power plants, the question is what to do with the toxic chemicals once they're prevented from going into the atmosphere. Or as Sen. Boxer said:

“We know that coal waste is so dangerous that we don’t want it in the air, and that’s why we’ve told power plants they have to install scrubbers,” said Senator Barbara Boxer, the California Democrat who is chairwoman of the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works. “So why are they dumping the same waste into people’s water?”

CCP.jpgWhile she has a very good point her question is rather disingenuous. Obviously if the toxic chemicals are removed from gaseous emissions the toxic chemicals still exist and have to be put somewhere, the question is "where"? The NY Times article goes on to discuss that "no federal regulations specifically govern the disposal of power plant discharges into waterways or landfills" and that some regulators attempt to use the Clean Water Act to regulate such emissions. The Clean Water Act is insufficient for this purpose and in any case the NY Times article reports even for plants who are regulated under this act the vast majority are in violation and are not fined or otherwise sanctioned by the agencies who would be regulating them.

The NY Times article states that often states fight against stricter regulations. An example is this listing by the DOE of state regulations in Kentucky ("Coal, Kentucky's Ace in the Hole"):

Current Regulations Governing Coal Combustion By-Products - Kentucky: Under Kentucky regulations, CCBs (including fly ash, bottom ash, and scrubber sludge produced by coal-fired electrical generating units) are exempt from regulation as hazardous wastes but are classified as special waste. Excluded from this regulation is boiler slag and residues of refuse-derived fuels such as municipal waste, tires, and solvents. Under Kentucky law, CCBs (as defined above) may be reused under permit by rule regulation 1) as an ingredient in manufacturing a product; 2) as an ingredient in cement, concrete, paint, and plastics; 3) as an anti-skid material; 4) as highway base course; 5) as structural fill; 6) as blasting grit; 7) as roofing granules; and 8) for disposal in an active mining operation if the mine owner/operator has a mining permit authorizing disposal of special waste. Specific conditions for reuse of CCBs include: 1) the CCB reuse may not create a nuisance; 2) erosion and sediment controls must be undertaken; 3) the CCB reuse must be at least 100 ft from a stream and 300 ft from potable wells, wetlands, or flood plains; 4) the ash must be "non-hazardous;" and 5) the generator must submit an annual report. Mine applications must be specifically authorized under the terms of a permit issued by the Department for Surface Mining, Reclamation and Enforcement.

Another example of the problem is this report by Califormia's Air Resources Board on Disposal of Scrubber Wastes (PDF). It's a very long report but begins with a discussion of the total scrubber waste which would come from eight utility and four utility sites being studied. Among the wastes is 9700 tons of "purge water" which would be produced and require disposal. The purge water was said to contain 70 percent solids so maybe the word "sludge" is better than "purge water"? In any case their casual use of this phrase, "purge water", indicates that for them this is a routine matter of course issue. Hence Sen. Boxer's incredulity quoted above seems misplaced or misinformed as someone in her position ought to already know about this issue.

Perhaps proving that "what goes around comes around", EPA Says Scrubbers Necessary for Health Protection Under Coal Conversion Plan is a historical press release from 1977 going over how "President Carter's Energy Plan calls for maximum conversion of this nation's electric power plants from oil to coal combustion". An issue facing the U.S. during the 1970's was repeated oil embargo's and additionally President Carter famously addressed the nation about the future danger that we now know as Peak Oil. Pres. Carter was prescient enough to see that oil supply problems would only get worse due to the majority of oil reserves being located in unfriendly countries. So he led the country to switch from oil fired electricity generation to coal fired electricity generation.

One of the already known phrases for this is "Coal Combustion Products" which are the byproducts generated from burning coal in coal-fired power plants. These byproducts include fly ash, bottom ash, boiler slag, and flue gas desulfurization gypsum. Astonishingly these CCP's are routinely used in a variety of building materials.

CCP Production In Tons
Concrete/Concrete Products/Grout 14,515,690
Blended Cement/ Raw Feed for Clinker 4,989,988
Flowable Fill 127,406
Structural Fills/Embankments 10,598,118
Road Base/Sub-base 1,179,509
Soil Modification/Stabilization 1,371,228
Mineral Filler in Asphalt 102,723
Snow and Ice Control 781,346
Blasting Grit/Roofing Granules 1,449,561
Mining Applications 6,701,910
Gypsum Panel Products 8,254,849
Waste Stabilization/Solidification 2,800,031
Agriculture 180,100
Aggregate 1,013,373
Miscellaneous/Other 1,973,173

The EPA claims some benefits of using these CCP's include

  • reduction of greenhouse gasses that would otherwise be created during concrete production
  • concrete with fly ash is stronger than other concrete
  • doesn't need to be put in landfills
  • reduces the amount of "virgin materials" which have to be mined

The EPA also lists some of the risks.

  • fly ash contains toxic materials such as "heavy metals" but "for all practical purposes" there is no leaching of those toxic materials
  • workers handling dry coal ash are of course exposed to these toxic materials
  • there is also "unencapsulated" uses of these materials (making concrete is an "encapsulated use") in which there is leaching of elements such as mercury and metals into ground water, contamination of vegetation and the impact on other elements on the food chain, and airborne dust.

The Recycled Materials Resource Center contains an extensive set of guidelines for reusing various "by-product materials" for use in "secondary applications". As they point out "virgin materials" are becoming scarce and the volume of "by-product materials" is increasing. Hence it makes sense to use those "by-product materials" in some other way, with highway construction being seen as a primary potential use. The guide is "intended to provide the reader with general guidance on engineering evaluation requirements, environmental issues, and economic considerations for determining the suitability of using recovered materials in highway applications".


allvoices

Tres Amigas Project in New Mexico promises more renewable energy through better electrical grid connectivity

A criticism of renewable energy resources like wind or solar power is the places where it's abundant are places with few people, and the places with many people don't have much of either wind or solar power. Thus to utilize wind or solar power means long distance electrical transmission through what's been characterized as an aging and inefficient national power grid. American Superconductor aims to undo this bottleneck with the Tres Amigas project which intends to be a highly efficient interconnection hub for the three main portions of America's power grid.

renewable-power.jpgThe "Saudi Arabia of Wind" is in the U.S. mid-west region, primarily a corridor from North Texas, along the front range of the Rockies, and into Wyoming and Minnesota. Similarly the deserts of the South West are prime places for solar power installations. Lots of wind and sun with few people, meaning that electricity from facilities installed there has to travel a long distance to reach their market. Further for that power to reach the east or west coast requires traversing what are said to be inefficient transfers to the Eastern or Western Interconnect.

tres-amigas.jpgThe design of the Tres Amigas project is a large triangle of underground superconducting cables connecting the three power grids. (get it? three power grids? tres amigas?) Each leg of the triangle can carry 5 gigawatts of electricity and the whole station will be on 22.5 square miles of land near Clovis NM.

A key component of the design is the "Superconductor Electricity Pipelines" product developed by American Superconductor. These pipelines have a copper core in a cryogenic environment maintained by a liquid nitrogen bath. Hence this form of superconductivity is created by supercold temperatures. The cables are buried underground by digging trenches creating an advantage over current long distance transmission using those tall towers which criss-cross the country. Their website is full of pictures of untouched rural landscapes which one supposes would result from widespread use of their electricity pipelines.

superconductive-cables.jpg

They claim the advantages of the "Superconductor Electricity Pipelines" include the following. However the claims are made for 1000 mile long transmission cables, and the Tres Amigas project is only due to cover a 22.5 square mile exchange point. It is not said whether this project includes any truly long distance transmission facilities beyond the exchange point.

  • Higher efficiency (97% rather than 91%) resulting in less transmission loss
  • Smaller land use impact (25 foot right of way versus 600 foot)
  • Good esthetics (buried cables are out of sight)
  • No electromagnetic field
  • Efficiency and CO2 emissions savings (presumably due to higher transmission efficiency)

Tres Amigas LLC claims these advantages:-

  • First system to connect America’s three power grids (Eastern Interconnect, Western Interconnect and Texas Interconnect)
  • Enhances the capacity, reliability and efficiency of America’s power grids
  • Assists the U.S. in achieving its renewable energy targets by carrying gigawatts of “green” power from region to region
  • Creates the nation’s first renewable energy trading hub
  • Utilizes the latest power grid technologies, including DC superconductor power cables, HVDC voltage source converters and energy storage systems

The project seems geared to tapping New Mexico's potential as a leading supplier of renewable energy. That and other state's of the South West have vast potential for producing renewably sourced electricity.

The information from Tres Amigas includes this curious statement: "Creates the nation’s first renewable energy trading hub". This raises echo's of Enron whose primary purpose was to operate an energy trading system.


allvoices

Monday, September 21, 2009

Solar power in the storage industry

DSCN0907-web.jpgMost use of the words "Solar Power" along with "Storage" have to do with energy storage because Solar and Wind power are both intermittent power sources. Because they're intermittent it's attractive to look at storing that electricity for later use. However I want to talk about another aspect of storage in conjunction with solar power. It's those businesses which offer "storage" services of a more personal sort. You know the place, a cheap piece of land, a long concrete block building, doors, locks, and a monthly fee to store your stuff.

What do they have to do with solar power? It's quite simple, these businesses have large flat roofs that are well exposed to the sun. Normally these businesses are located away from other buildings meaning there's little shade etc. These attributes make it great for collecting solar power.

In other words the typical storage business would make a great location to install solar power. And it's not just those businesses because there are lots of modern office buildings with flat roofs, the large majority of which are well exposed to the sun and would make a great place to put solar panels.

One quibble which comes to mind however is the utility companies & the power system in the U.S. is not configured to support a large number of small power stations. Instead it's configured to support a small number of large power stations, ones that produce 100 megawatts or more of electricity.

For example homeowners who buy solar power for their house might have dreams of getting rich selling power to the power company. It would certainly turn the world on its head if home owners were in the position of selling power to the power company. But for example in California we have "Net Metering" which means the power a home owner supplies to the grid is taken off their utility bill, but if they provide more to the grid than their utility bill they do not get that money. Under Net Metering a home owner can only be compensated by the utility company up to the amount they use.

Perhaps these storage companies or office parks could, being businesses, negotiate a different power arrangement with the power companies. That is if you owned one of those storage companies wouldn't you like the opportunity to make some side income?

This is so obvious an idea to me that I'm surprised nobody has thought to do it. Maybe there's a kink in it along the lines of the Net Metering ridiculosity.


allvoices

Friday, September 11, 2009

Easy Energy Systems

Description: 

Specializes in the manufacture and support of Modular Ethanol Production Systems (MEPS).

Their Modular Ethanol Production Systems are:

  • Fully Automatic
  • Scalable
  • Efficient Production
  • Increased Safety and Byproduct Feed Value
  • Durable Construction
  • Price Protection Hedge
  • Easily Shipped and Installed
  • Environmentally Friendly


allvoices

Thursday, September 3, 2009

UK Industry Taskforce on Peak Oil and Energy Security (ITPOES)

Description: 

A group of British companies concerned that threats to energy security are not receiving the attention they merit.


allvoices

Thursday, July 16, 2009

Desertec Foundation

Description: 

"The DESERTEC Foundation is intended to serve as a hub for realizing the DESERTEC Concept. It will also work for creating a global alliance to ensure security of energy supplies, to promote economic development, and to stabilize the world’s climate." The web site shows a picture of the earth, but centered on the frame of Europe and North Africa. Some pictures show a network of lines between North Africa and Europe. "The DESERTEC Concept describes the perspective of a sustainable supply of electricity for Europe (EU), the Middle East (ME) and North Africa (NA) up to the year 2050. It shows that a transition to competitive, secure and compatible supply is possible using renewable energy sources and efficiency gains, and fossil fuels as backup for balancing power."

The site seems purposed towards ensuring Europe has a source of electricity, and that Europe sees a lot of desert in North Africa upon which various sorts of solar power collecting systems can be installed. The idea would be to build transmission lines between North Africa and Europe to send the power to Europe. In other words it's a form of "How did our oil get under their sand" but for a renewable resource. Clearly if North Africa wants to set itself up as an electricity producer for Europe it could be mutually beneficial.

The site also lists Desertec projects around the world and obviously there are desert areas with a lot of Sunlight who could produce renewably sourced electricity for transmission to other areas.


allvoices

Choose Ethanol

Description: 

Published by the Renewable Fuels Association, they present information about ethanol, why it's not bad, why it doesn't impact food prices, where to get it, etc.


allvoices